I was disappointed to hear Judge Judy yesterday. I was in someone else's living room where the program was airing, and I remember finding her funny so I sat down to watch. Who can resist the author of Don't Pee on My Leg and Tell Me it's Raining?
Well, Judge Judy happened to be berating a 19-year-old tenant who was sexually harassed in Huntington Beach by her landlord. The young woman was seeking her last month's rent back after she moved out. Her landlord allegedly turned off her electricity when she complained about the harassment, which included the man's uncle watching pornography whenever she was coming up (there were no window shades); asking her why she minds pornography--"Why, are you a virgin?"--and asking if the young woman was going to have "sexual relations" with her (girl) friend who stayed over night.
I am no certainly no legal expert, and it could be that Judge Judy was right that she couldn't legally break the lease based on this behavior alone. There was some question about whether the electricity stoppage was due to an accident or was malicious (although I'm inclined to guess the latter). But the way Judge Judy spoke to her, she was basically castigating this young woman for being overly sensitive, saying things like she needed to go to school to know how to respond to these characters; that "the fact that you didn't like the chatter, is not sufficient basis to break the lease." To me, the situation sounded like a bit more than mere "chatter."
Then Judge Judy advised her to rent from a "little old lady" next time, and asked her once again, to great comic effect, if she was currently renting "from a little old lady?" I felt it was unnecessary to repeatedly make fun of someone who had already endured harassment. (Indeed, it encouraged the landord himself to laugh at the young woman's face in the courtroom, which seemed highly inappropriate.)
Now, the grizzly-looking man did not escape her ridicule either--Judge Judy referred to him sarcastically as "God's gift." But I guess I've grown weary of adults telling young women that their instincts are bad.
The law is one thing, but if anyone deserved to be castigated, it was the man for his crude behavior, not this young woman for being too sensitive. Thoughts?
To my amusement, while outside the courtroom, the young woman told a reporter that she had drawn her own lesson from the incident: "Don't rent from weirdos on Craig's List," she concluded.
Recent Comments